In Twilight, Don't you think alice should have heard james tricking bella in the hotel room?

I was just re-reading it and i thought that alice should be able to hear James talking to bella on the cell phone, what with her super sensitive hearing and all that.





Or wouldn't she have had any visions about him tricking her?





i was just wondering what your opinion on the matter was.In Twilight, Don't you think alice should have heard james tricking bella in the hotel room?
Yeah, you're right. The thought has come to my mind occasionally too. But I agree with the other person on here, that she was probably to preoccupied by trying to give her some privacy.In Twilight, Don't you think alice should have heard james tricking bella in the hotel room?
This ones a little tricky. I agree that's its a little bit of both answers, the whole privacy thing and the recorded message, but what I don't get is why Alice didn't have a vision in the airport when Bella decided to run. I know Bella had it in her head that she was going to the studio, but it wasn't until they got to the airport that she devised her escape plan to run through the bathroom. You would think then Alice would have had a vision, but I guess you could say she was preoccupied then waiting for Edward to get off the plane. Sometimes I think its best to not really dwell on these things bc you start questioning the book and its written to entertain you. When you start getting logical it takes all the fun out of the story. :)
No.





Remember, James got a recorded message of Renee, Bella's mom so if Alice had been listening she would have thought it Bella was talking to Renee.


She didn't have a vision about James, because Bella would have thought about her mom purposely, so that is what Alice would have seen, and not James.





xxx GG
I don't think her hearing is that sensitive. Bella was in the other room with the door closed, and she was saying what james told her to. Plus, Bella never decided to do anything until she ran away in the airport.
It's called a plot device. The author needed for Alice not to hear, or toknow, therefore she didn't.





Good authors keep their plot devices consistent throughout their books. Bad ones don't.
yeah, but she was proably a bit preoccupied by wat she had seen and trying 2 give bella some privacy. also she had a vision of the room - she just didnt know how bella got there.
Bit of a flaw in the plan there.





Your right.

ENAS SA